[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[McIDAS #OKG-462913]: Color Bar and Units when channel differencing



Hi Greg,

This note is not the definitive answer you are looking for.  Please read
on.

re:
> Ok - I understand the details of how to do the channel differencing
> with IMGOPER.

OK.

> It's when I get to the color bar that I am confused.

My original inclination was that this should be straightforward.  After
looking at the problem in detail last night, however, I find that the
situation is quite a bit more complicated.  The main reason for the
complication, at least for GOES data, is the two-slope calibration
that the images follow.

If we are talking about GOES images, the the calibration of brightness
to temperature for infrared images is represented by the values in the
stretch table IRTEMP.ST (I created the stretch IRTEMP.ST using the standard
GOES calibration):

SU TABLE IRTEMP
BREAKPOINTS STORED IN TABLE : IRTEMP.ST
INPUT       OUTPUT
-----       ------
 163           255
 241.9999      177
 242           176
 330           0
CALIBRATION TYPE  : GVAR
CALIBRATION UNITS : TEMP
BAND NUMBER       : -1
INTERPOLATION TYPE: LIN
SU: DONE

The two-slope calibration indicates that the the same difference in brightness
will represent different temperature differences depending on the original
brightness values for the IR (10.7 um) and IRS (IR short, 3.9 um) images.
This difference is well illustrated by the scatter plot contained in the 
attachment
I have included.  The axes in the scatter plot are:

X -> 63 + (irBrit - irsBrit)
Y -> 63 + (irTemp - irsTemp)

Notice how the scatter plot illustrates the two slope calibration effect.

The two-slope relationship is likely the reason that IMGOPER did not
provide a correct PRD calibration in the output image created by
IMGOPER when specifying UNIT=TEMP.  I think that it should have, but
I will contact SSEC for comment.

Nonetheless, I _think_ that one should be able to create a stretch table
that captures the essence of the two-slope calibration.  This stretch
table would then be used in a BAR labeling of the product generated
with IMGOPER as:

BAR SU=IRDELT

where IRDELT.ST is the as yet non-existent stretch table.

> So
> I've done a channel differencing using UNIT=TEMP. If I do an IMGPROBE on
> the results, I see numbers like: RAW=160 BRIT=160  PROD=160 etc. The
> values vary but RAW=BRIT=PROD is always true.

I am not surprised that the RAW=BRIT since the image will be calibrated.
I am surprised by PROD also having the same value AND there is not a TEMP
value.  This is something I will need to discuss with SSEC.

> If I type BAR to put a color bar on the image, I get a 0-255
> grayscale that has the word PROD above the scale but BRIT above the
> numbers.

This agrees with PROD=BRIT.  The question is why the PRD value doesn't
reflect the fact that the values are a difference?!

> Ideally I'd like the units to be TEMP and the range to scale
> from -5 to +10.

My conjecture is that one should be able to create a stretch table that
represents the temperature difference values in spite of the two-slope
calibrations.  I am playing with this now, and will send you my results
if/when I am satisfied with them.

> When I ran the IMGOPER command I used the same ACON and
> MCON as suggested in the fog product demo (150 and 10).

OK.

> Is it possible to get the colorbar to read the way I want it to?

I believe so.

> If yes, how do I do that?

I'm working on it...

Cheers,

Tom
****************************************************************************
Unidata User Support                                    UCAR Unidata Program
(303) 497-8642                                                 P.O. Box 3000
address@hidden                                   Boulder, CO 80307
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unidata HomePage                       http://www.unidata.ucar.edu
****************************************************************************


Ticket Details
===================
Ticket ID: OKG-462913
Department: Support McIDAS
Priority: Normal
Status: Open

Attachment: irTirsT_irBifsB.gif
Description: GIF image


NOTE: All email exchanges with Unidata User Support are recorded in the Unidata inquiry tracking system and then made publicly available through the web. If you do not want to have your interactions made available in this way, you must let us know in each email you send to us.