Thanks to Daryl Herzmann and Ryan Hickman for figuring this out! As for the
reason for change, I'll just shrug at that one...
Then again, I'm still confused as to why RUC2 isn't RAP and why several other
feed entries make zero sense (e.g., MRMS). Meh.
--
Dr. Vittorio (Victor) A. Gensini
Associate Professor
Meteorology
College of DuPage
425 Fawell Blvd.
Glen Ellyn, IL 60137
Office: Berg Instructional Center 3503
ph: +1 (630) 942-3496
http://weather.cod.edu/~vgensini
On Aug 25, 2016, at 6:09 PM, Ryan Hickman
<ryan@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx<mailto:ryan@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>> wrote:
20160825T225946.888925Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
56508 20160825225944.465083 NGRID 20526853 LUDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F017/UREL/30-0 hPa PDLY
20160825T225946.928740Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
48876 20160825225944.470465 NGRID 20526854 LRDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F017/RELH/180-150 hPa PDLY
20160825T225946.929497Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
35365 20160825225945.271612 NGRID 20526864 LVDZ12 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F015/VREL/125 hPa PRES
20160825T225949.698165Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
29946 20160825225949.697962 HDS 81317554 LZDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F019/HLCY/3000-0 m HGHT
20160825T225950.137091Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
44438 20160825225950.136893 HDS 81317765 LYDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F019/CIN/255-0 hPa PDLY
20160825T225950.147939Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
54336 20160825225950.147736 HDS 81317779 LWDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F019/CAPE/255-0 hPa PDLY
20160825T225950.332050Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
63261 20160825225950.331796 HDS 81317780 LZDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F019/HLCY/1000-0 m HGHT
20160825T225959.727083Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
45128 20160825225959.726862 NGRID 20527040 LHDZ45 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F016/HGHT/450 hPa PRES
20160825T230004.601507Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
56860 20160825230004.601274 NGRID 20527137 LHDN93 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F018/HGHT/975 hPa PRES
20160825T230004.787309Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
63141 20160825230004.787128 HDS 81318525 LZDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F020/HLCY/1000-0 m HGHT
20160825T230005.009994Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
46513 20160825230005.009756 HDS 81318612 LYDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F020/CIN/255-0 hPa PDLY
20160825T230005.015628Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
29528 20160825230005.015419 HDS 81318618 LZDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F020/HLCY/3000-0 m HGHT
20160825T230005.031800Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
55522 20160825230005.031612 HDS 81318640 LWDZ86 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F020/CAPE/255-0 hPa PDLY
20160825T230005.081077Z notifyme[15273] INFO notifyme.c:222:notifymeprog_5()
44954 20160825230005.080847 NGRID 20527165 LHDN99 KWBG 252200
!grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/201608252200F018/HGHT/1000 hPa PRES
If you run `notifyme` without the -f flag, I think you'll find what you're
looking for. It appears they're now sending those products out via HDS instead
of NGRID which causes all of our request/pqact entries to fail only on those
products.
On Thu, Aug 25, 2016 at 4:04 PM, Gensini, Vittorio
<gensiniv@xxxxxxx<mailto:gensiniv@xxxxxxx>> wrote:
Hi all,
Please see this e-mail chain below. Basically, there are grids now missing
from the RAP130 NGRID NOAAport feed (post Tuesday's switch). They are the same
grids missing that were changed in the TIN message. Hopefully there is someone
on this list that can solve the problem.
Best,
vg
__________________________
Vittorio (Victor) A. Gensini, Ph.D.
Associate Professor, Meteorology
College of DuPage
e: gensiniv@xxxxxxx<mailto:gensiniv@xxxxxxx> | p:
(630)-942-3496<tel:%28630%29-942-3496>
http://weather.cod.edu/~vgensini
From: Carissa Klemmer - NOAA Federal
<carissa.l.klemmer@xxxxxxxx<mailto:carissa.l.klemmer@xxxxxxxx>>
Date: Thursday, August 25, 2016 4:41 PM
To: Victor Gensini <gensiniv@xxxxxxx<mailto:gensiniv@xxxxxxx>>
Cc: Geoffrey Manikin - NOAA Federal
<geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx<mailto:geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx>>,
"curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx<mailto:curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx>"
<curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx<mailto:curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx>>, Corey Guastini -
NOAA Affiliate <corey.guastini@xxxxxxxx<mailto:corey.guastini@xxxxxxxx>>,
"ncep.list.pmb-dataflow@xxxxxxxx<mailto:ncep.list.pmb-dataflow@xxxxxxxx>"
<ncep.list.pmb-dataflow@xxxxxxxx<mailto:ncep.list.pmb-dataflow@xxxxxxxx>>
Subject: Re: Grids missing from the RAP 130 grid
Sorry I didn't email yesterday. I called the NCF and asked their tech team to
check the logs and ensure these new WMO headers were being up linked to
noaaport. I got confirmation that they see the 86 headers and were sent to
noaaport. I'm a little stuck now. At this point I would probably suggest going
to unidata ldm forum and ask if anyone else is seeing them. Get some smart ldm
people involved. Do you have a POC for them?
Carissa
Touched, not typed
On Aug 25, 2016, at 14:08, Gensini, Vittorio
<gensiniv@xxxxxxx<mailto:gensiniv@xxxxxxx>> wrote:
Hi Geoff,
Any update on the cause of this?
Best,
__
Dr. Vittorio (Victor) A. Gensini
Associate Professor
Meteorology
College of DuPage
President, Chicago Chapter of the American Meteorological Society
425 Fawell Blvd.
Glen Ellyn, IL 60137
Office: Berg Instructional Center (BIC) 3503
ph: +1 (630) 942-3496<tel:%2B1%20%28630%29%20942-3496>
http://weather.cod.edu/~vgensini
________________________________
From: Geoffrey Manikin - NOAA Federal
<geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx<mailto:geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx>>
Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 3:41 PM
To: Gensini, Vittorio
Cc: curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx<mailto:curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx>;
carissa.l.klemmer@xxxxxxxx<mailto:carissa.l.klemmer@xxxxxxxx>; Corey Guastini -
NOAA Affiliate
Subject: Re: Grids missing from the RAP 130 grid
Carissa-
The 4 files missing in the 13 km RAP AWIPS files are the 4 that we
mentioned in the RAP13 AWIPS TIN for which the headers were changing.
We're correctly processing all of them, so does this mean that some
group downstream was not prepared for this change??
-Geoff
On Tue, Aug 23, 2016 at 4:36 PM, Gensini, Vittorio
<gensiniv@xxxxxxx<mailto:gensiniv@xxxxxxx>> wrote:
Hi Geoff,
Found them, I was wrong about CIN. All four are the changes mentioned in the
TIN message. I ran a quick DIF checker and found removal of:
CIN255-0 mb above ground
CAPE255-0 mb above ground
HLCY1000-0 m above ground
HLCY3000-0 m above ground
Probably the ones you were expecting. Let us know if/when they are added back
to the NOAAport stream.
Best,
__
Dr. Vittorio (Victor) A. Gensini
Associate Professor
Meteorology
College of DuPage
President, Chicago Chapter of the American Meteorological Society
425 Fawell Blvd.
Glen Ellyn, IL 60137
Office: Berg Instructional Center (BIC) 3503
ph: +1 (630) 942-3496<tel:%2B1%20%28630%29%20942-3496>
http://weather.cod.edu/~vgensini
________________________________
From: Geoffrey Manikin - NOAA Federal
<geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx<mailto:geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx>>
Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 3:12 PM
To: Gensini, Vittorio
Subject: Re: Grids missing from the RAP 130 grid
Victor-
Knowing the exact dropouts would probably be a good thing. Thanks for
offering.
-Geoff
On Tue, Aug 23, 2016 at 4:10 PM, Gensini, Vittorio
<gensiniv@xxxxxxx<mailto:gensiniv@xxxxxxx>> wrote:
Thanks for your speedy response Geoff!
I can confirm that the changed entries in your document:
"The headers for helicity are changed from ‘LZD*98 KWBG’ to ‘LZD*86 KWBG’ The
headers for 0255 mb cape is changed from ‘LWD*98 KWBG’ to ‘LZD*86 KWBG’"
Are not coming in after using LDM 'notifyme.' Strangely, 0-255mb CIN is
working just fine.
I can compare pre and post upgrade to get you the exact dropouts if needed.
Best,
__
Dr. Vittorio (Victor) A. Gensini
Associate Professor
Meteorology
College of DuPage
President, Chicago Chapter of the American Meteorological Society
425 Fawell Blvd.
Glen Ellyn, IL 60137
Office: Berg Instructional Center (BIC) 3503
ph: +1 (630) 942-3496<tel:%2B1%20%28630%29%20942-3496>
http://weather.cod.edu/~vgensini
________________________________
From: Geoffrey Manikin - NOAA Federal
<geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx<mailto:geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx>>
Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 3:01 PM
To: Gensini, Vittorio
Cc: curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx<mailto:curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx>;
ncep.list.pmb-dataflow@xxxxxxxx<mailto:ncep.list.pmb-dataflow@xxxxxxxx>; Corey
Guastini - NOAA Affiliate
Subject: Re: Grids missing from the RAP 130 grid
hi Victor-
The issues must be downstream of us, as the RAP 130 grids that we're
sending to NOAAPORT have 292 records now, and the cycles before the upgrade had
292 as well.
Per that document, we changed the headers for 4 parameters, so it
sounds like those 4 are falling on the floor somewhere down the line. I
can't yet account for the other two.
-Geoff
On Tue, Aug 23, 2016 at 3:40 PM, Gensini, Vittorio
<gensiniv@xxxxxxx<mailto:gensiniv@xxxxxxx>> wrote:
Hi Geoff,
We were matching the grids with anything from (L.D...), as you say in your
document here:
http://www.nco.ncep.noaa.gov/pmb/changes/docs/AWIPS_RAPv3_130.pdf
We have also used:
NGRID grib2/ncep/RUC2/#130/(..)(..)(....)(....)F(...)
FILE /home/data/models/rap/\2\3\4F\5.rap
To match *anything* from the RAP NGRID feed.
Running wgrib2 on the files since 12Z today shows that there were 292 grids
before the upgrade and 286 after (we eliminate the aviation flight level
products).
I haven't sorted through exactly which have been dropped, but at least two of
them are 0-1 and 0-3 SRH.
Best,
__
Dr. Vittorio (Victor) A. Gensini
Associate Professor
Meteorology
College of DuPage
President, Chicago Chapter of the American Meteorological Society
425 Fawell Blvd.
Glen Ellyn, IL 60137
Office: Berg Instructional Center (BIC) 3503
ph: +1 (630) 942-3496<tel:%2B1%20%28630%29%20942-3496>
http://weather.cod.edu/~vgensini
________________________________
From: Geoffrey Manikin - NOAA Federal
<geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx<mailto:geoffrey.manikin@xxxxxxxx>>
Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 2:25 PM
To: Gensini, Vittorio
Cc: curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx<mailto:curtis.alexander@xxxxxxxx>;
ncep.list.pmb-dataflow@xxxxxxxx<mailto:ncep.list.pmb-dataflow@xxxxxxxx>; Corey
Guastini - NOAA Affiliate
Subject: Re: Grids missing from the RAP 130 grid
hi Victor-
In the document
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-k5tKCQjS7a55Y1IUHuQSpLXXbIcvb1LZtEjdKmePsY/edit
please note section 5. Helicity had been identified as a surface field
which really isn't right, so it was changed with this upgrade. The new
headers should be easy to find.
-Geoff
p.s. I shared the document with you.
On Tue, Aug 23, 2016 at 3:21 PM, Gensini, Vittorio
<gensiniv@xxxxxxx<mailto:gensiniv@xxxxxxx>> wrote:
Hi Geoff/Curtis/Carissa,
Beginning with today's 1200 UTC update for the RAP 130 grid, I no longer see
HLCY 0-1000 m and HLCY 0-3000m being transmitted over the SBN NOAAport feed. I
saw no changes with the HRRR grib2 files, but it was my impression from the
para feeds that the 0-1 and 0-3 SRH fields would still be a part of the RAP
post-processed fields from NCEP.
As you know, they are important variables for calculation and use in convective
forecasting, and I hope they return soon!
Best,
__
Dr. Vittorio (Victor) A. Gensini
Associate Professor
Meteorology
College of DuPage
President, Chicago Chapter of the American Meteorological Society
425 Fawell Blvd.
Glen Ellyn, IL 60137
Office: Berg Instructional Center (BIC) 3503
ph: +1 (630) 942-3496<tel:%2B1%20%28630%29%20942-3496>
http://weather.cod.edu/~vgensini
_______________________________________________
NOTE: All exchanges posted to Unidata maintained email lists are
recorded in the Unidata inquiry tracking system and made publicly
available through the web. Users who post to any of the lists we
maintain are reminded to remove any personal information that they
do not want to be made public.
ldm-users mailing list
ldm-users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx<mailto:ldm-users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
For list information or to unsubscribe, visit:
http://www.unidata.ucar.edu/mailing_lists/
