[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[netCDF #MSV-188900]: C++ API for NETCDF version 4.0

Replying to my own email, here's the explanation from Ed about
why what I did appeared to work.  It's not inheritance at all,
it's just that the types are global:

  Actually the type path is never needed. The typeid is file global,
  but the catch is you must scan the whole file to find where the
  types are hidden.

  So if you tuck all your types away when writing the file, you make
  it hard for the reader to find them, but they are still global, and
  once the reader does find them, only the typeid is needed.

  Inheritance is not appropriate for types in a data file, I
  think. Too complicated! Containment of named types is really all you
  need. If there is a lot of commonality of type metadata, define some
  core types, and use arrays and vlens of those...

  OK, this is odd, but I just looked, and there is no way at all to
  look up types by name. You can provide a group, and learn all the
  typeids in that group, but you can not provide a name, and get a
  typeid.

  Probably this is a mistake and I need to add this function (not for
  4.0.1 obviously, but for 4.1).

I also asked if we could add type inheritance in a future version in a
backward-compatible way, because any files that rely on such
inheritance would just not be valid today, but making that change
would give them a consistent meaning.  That actually holds for other
kinds of inheritance too, such as inheriting coordinate variables and
attributes along the Group hierarchy.

Ed responded

  It is true that this could be done in a backward compatible way.

  Using inheritance, as with dimensions, makes conceptual sense too.

  Clearly C++ has many opportunities to present a less primitive
  looking API. I look forward to seeing what he comes up with.

--Russ

Russ Rew                                         UCAR Unidata Program
address@hidden                     http://www.unidata.ucar.edu



Ticket Details
===================
Ticket ID: MSV-188900
Department: Support netCDF
Priority: Normal
Status: Closed