[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[Support #RQS-322086]: LDM Feedtype Questions



Jon,

> My name is Jon Hurst, I work with James Pelagatti at MIT/Lincoln
> Laboratory.  We are currently altering our LDM setup so we can serve
> some internal data to outside organizations and we had some questions
> about how to choose a feedtype.   I realize that we could technically
> choose any feedtype, and for testing we have been using EXP and also
> FSL2, but in the long term perspective we were thinking it might be
> worth establishing our own feedtype for the Lab.  If we do not create
> our own feedtype, I suppose we'll have to piggyback off of some other
> feed, or perhaps use the default ANY or EXP feedtypes.  Here are my
> questions in a semi-concise form:
> 
> - How frequently are new feedtypes added and when does a distribution
> site qualify for its own feedtype?  Might we qualify?

The LDM feedtype is represented as a 32-bit, unsigned integer with each
bit corresponding to a primitive feedtype.  As a consequence, only 32
primitive feedtypes are possible.  Increasing the number of feedtypes
would entail a change to the protocol and more than a little bit of
programming.

> - How much work would be involved with adding a new feedtype?  It looks
> like we would need to modify atofeedt.c, ldm.h and feedtypes.xml.  I
> guess the problem is ensuring that clients connecting to our server have
> a version of ldm that recognizes our new feedtype.  Is it common
> practice to use the ANY or EXP feedtype in the short term with the goal
> of switching to a unique feedtype upon the arrival of the next LDM version?

I suggest using the EXP feedtype and choosing your product-identifiers very
carefully so that they uniquely identify the data-products and are easily
selected via regular expressions.  We, typically, recommend that the first
component of such a product-identifier be an institutional or project name.

> Any feedback would be very helpful.  Thank you for your time.  LDM has
> been a great help!

I'm glad to hear that.

I'm currently working on an LDM replacement that won't have a problem with
a limited number of feedtypes.  Unfortunately, it won't be out until next
year.

Regards,
Steve Emmerson

Ticket Details
===================
Ticket ID: RQS-322086
Department: Support LDM
Priority: Normal
Status: Closed


NOTE: All email exchanges with Unidata User Support are recorded in the Unidata inquiry tracking system and then made publicly available through the web. If you do not want to have your interactions made available in this way, you must let us know in each email you send to us.